RC

Ritika Chitlangia

Question 9GS2GS2

Highlighting the concerns related to the Terms of Reference (TOR) of the Fifteenth Finance Commission discuss how the commission has balanced conflicting interests.

Open scan (p.25)

Introduction

The 15th Finance Commission is a constitutional body, constituted after 5 years by the President (Article 280). This present commission is headed by N.K. Singh.

25 words

Main Body

It was presented & reports - Interim report (2020-21) - Final Report (2021-2026) Concerns related to Terms of Reference: 1) Criteria for devolution - demographic change refurs to Total Fertility Ratio divide between northern & southern states. 2) Decreased devolution of funds from union to state to 41%. Due to addition of Jammu and Kashmir. 3) Usurped the virtual from forest to forest and ecology ⟹ bias towards states with population pressure and higher forest cover. 4) Devolution of grants to local bodies made conditional on performance audits, mechanisms and

foundation of state finance commission. 5) Belongs in formation of 16th Finance Commission. Balancing conflicting interests: 1) North-South divide - The southern states feel distant due to non-appreciation & advancement of decreasing TFR ⟹ Northern states get greater devolution due to 'higher population'. ⟹ FC too tied to resolve this. 2) Differences in North-east - Greater forest & ecology cover but income distance normal and high ⟹ Finance commission was tied to ensure fair and transparent functioning. 3) Parity of resources to local bodies - but revised based devolution well enhance accountability and sustainability.

4End of 5-year compensation period for GST by unite ⟹ responsibility of Finance commission along with GST council to come with new solutions. 5) Conflict over categorization of 'special status for certain states' – biased veteria by FC to ensure fair and transparent functioning. Thus, Finance Commission plays an incredibly important role in ensuring equality and inter-states equity in development. However, to order for it to be truly effective, its order recommendations should be made mandatory, a permanent Finance Commission should be set up, to ensure continuity in policy.
274 words1 paragraphs

Conclusion

Thus, Finance Commission plays an incredibly important role in ensuring equality and inter-states equity in development. However, to order for it to be truly effective, its order recommendations should be made mandatory, a permanent Finance Commission should be set up, to ensure continuity in policy.

45 words

Topper

Ritika Chitlangia

Subject & Paper

GS2GS2

Topic

Federal Structure - Functions, Responsibilities, Devolution of Powers and Finances

Centre-State Financial Relations

Fifteenth Finance Commission and TOR

Writing Stats

344

Total words

1

Paragraphs

analytical

Tone