N

NAUSHEENAIR 9· 2023

Question Q.1DiscussGS2GS2

There is a need to resolve the ambiguity in the disqualification provisions under section 8 of the Representation of People Act 1951. Discuss.

Open scan (p.1)

Main Body

Section 8 of Representation of People Act, 1951 deals with disqualification provisions. Article 103 deals with the power of election commission to advise president on disqualification. Ambiguity in the disqualification provisions: (1) Sections of the Act, allow ECI to reduce the period of disqualification (discretionary exercise) (2) Section 4, on immediate disqualification upon senhor for 2 or more years. (3) Provision on hate speech. This ambiguity have resulted in cases like Tamang case - where ECI exercised its discretionary power in a doubtful manner.

Need to resolve ambiguity: (1) to reduce criminalization of politics (4S) by section 2,7,8 of Lokpal Sabha (2) to ensure proper functioning of the parliament eg.) disqualification proceeding against opposition minister in absence of qualifiability (3) restricting the power of ECI to ensure 'free and fair' mechanism. Supreme court has tried to reduce the ambiguity in several cases (eg.) Lily Thomas case - strucking down section 4 - preventing disqualification in case of appeal.

158 words1 paragraphs

Diagram

Branching diagram showing: 'Need to resolve ambiguity' with three main branches: (1) to reduce criminalization of politics (4S) by section 2,7,8 of Lokpal Sabha, (2) to ensure proper functioning of the parliament eg.) disqualification proceeding against opposition minister in absence of qualifiability, (3) restricting the power of ECI to ensure 'free and fair' mechanism.

Topper

NAUSHEEN

AIR 92023

Subject & Paper

GS2GS2

Topic

Salient Features of the Representation of People's Act

Corrupt Practices

Disqualification ambiguity

Writing Stats

158

Total words

1

Paragraphs

analytical

Tone