KN

K N Chandana JahnaviAIR 50

Question Q.14GS2GS2

S.R. Bommai v. Union of India signified a paradigm shift in the judicial interpretation of the union's authority to assume control of a state's administration. In this context discuss the significance and impact of the judgement on cementing the federal structure.

Open scan (p.35)

Main Body

S.R. Bommai case has led to establishing JUDICIAL interpretation of IDEAL CENTRE-STATE relations by outlining FEDERALISM as part of BASIC STRUCTURE doctrine. The diagram shows: Role in Present rule declaration (Act 356 & 365): S.R BOMMAI CASE with Clarity on centre-led relations affecting Secularism as BASIC structure and Federalism on basic structure. In this context, COURT's shift came in the judgment of UNION's authority to declare

President rule in STATE and when it is LEGITIMATE: 1. It held Governeur on President satisfaction can be called into JUDICIAL review, example: Maharashtra governor in SC (2023). 2. It led to Court outlining when it is legitimate for President rule, example: in Bihar (2005) dissolving legislator with valid weightage. 3. It led to establishing Majority in ruling state government to file case on ORIGINAL jurisdiction under Article 131, example: Maharashtra-I line case. 4. It has limited measure of governor discretion for Article 256. Limited misuse of governor discretion for Article 256. Example: MANIPUR government not dismissed inspite of Tension under 356.

A central STATE government stability even with opposition parts eying at centre. Limited misuse of governor discretion for Article 256. Created JUDICIAL application on STATE's part for any transgress as CONTEMPT of court (A/C 129). IMPACT of Judgement: 1. Creation of glory STATES in BASIC federal structure. 2. Led to prioritising of dispute resolution. Example: In MANIPUR, Article 355 was used. Punchhi Commission recommended locused emergency. However major contention on Governor, state-religion legislations, taxation, inter-state disputes must be resolved with Cooperative federalism, as outlined by Firm Ministers.

255 words1 paragraphs

Conclusion

However major contention on Governor, state-religion legislations, taxation, inter-state disputes must be resolved with Cooperative federalism, as outlined by Firm Ministers.

21 words

Diagram

Diagram showing S.R. BOMMAI CASE as central node with branches for: Role in President rule declaration (Act 356, 365), Clarity on centre-led relations affecting Secularism as BASIC structure, and Federalism on basic structure

Topper

K N Chandana Jahnavi

AIR 50

Subject & Paper

GS2GS2

Topic

Federal Structure - Functions, Responsibilities, Devolution of Powers and Finances

Federalism

Center-State relations

Writing Stats

276

Total words

1

Paragraphs

analytical

Tone