AS

Abhishek Singh· 2024

Question 0-16GS2GS2

Relating to ordinances have always raised concerns about the violation of the spirit of Constitution which embodies national sovereignty and Justifying the power to promulgate, analyse whether the division of SC on the issue has further obfuscated presenting the power. Should power to promulgate ordinance be disputed?

Open scan (p.15)

Main Body

President under Article 123 and Governors under Article 213 can promulgate ordinance. Rationale for this power: Justification: (1) Legislature not in session: This power is used during recess of legislatures to fulfill some immediate and urgent need. (2) During CoVID-S: Recent example of Covid-19 when parliament could not hold sessions, the promulgating power ensured that necessary laws to deal with situations got framed. Supreme Court has given many judgements regarding Use and misuse of this Power. Important judgements: (1) R.C Copper Case(1970): President's satisfaction about immediate need of ordinance is subject to judicial review on ground of being blatant. (2) D.C Wadhwa Case (1987): a Bishai government kept repromulgating the same ordinance for 256 times. SC said this as unconstitutional. Excessive repromulgation without laying it before legislature is ultra vires. b Ordinance is not a substitute to powers of legislature.

3Keshavananda Bharti Case: Separation of power is basic structure. Trends in Ordinances: (1) Numbers increased: In 1950 the average ordinance was 7.1/year. It increased to 25 in 2020 (PRS data). (2) Repromulgation of ordinances by president has not decreased for eg: Tribunals reforms ordinance, Indian medical Council amendment ordinance. (3) States are also secretory to ordinance voice exclusively for eg: Kerala govt issued 8 ordinances in 2020 (PRS data). (4) However there are many genuine case of ordinance must. for eg: Ordinance related to disaster management during Covid-19. So decision of SC has forthfully stopped the misuse of ordinance making power. But despite this ordinance making power should not be repeated because: (1) It fulfills legislative vacuum. (2) Misuse does not imply repealing of law. It implies the restraint on the part of executive as there is nothing wrong with the law. (3) Hopes during CoVID and Emergency Separation of power and checks and balances are core spirit of Constitution. The power of ordinance should be used as a last resort and not daily affairs.
316 words1 paragraphs

Topper

Abhishek Singh

2024Polity

Subject & Paper

GS2GS2

Topic

Indian Constitution - Historical Underpinnings, Evolution, Features, Amendments, Significant Provisions and Basic Structure

Significant Provisions

Presidential Ordinance Powers

Writing Stats

316

Total words

1

Paragraphs

analytical

Tone