W

WASIM-UR-RAHMANAIR 157· 2025

Question Q.14GS2GS2

Parliamentary privileges are fundamental for lawmakers to discharge their duties without undue influence. How important is the responsible exercise of these privileges in crucial for fostering public trust and ensuring the accountability of public institutions. Analyse.

Open scan (p.32)

Main Body

Article 105 and 194 provides for the basis of parliamentary privileges. India adopted UK's convention on parliamentary privileges (Right to Free Speech & publication) to ensure Separation of Power. SIGNIFICANCE OF PARLIAMENTARY PRIVILEGES: 1) [Separation of Power] is ensured by restricting Judicial inquiry into parliamentary functioning (Article 122) 2) [Free Speech] on the floor of house enable legislators to write the concerns of their constituency. 3) [Pursuing for the Contempt of House] act as deterrent force against

Spread of false information & Scandalization 4) Privileges for members of house allow their effective participation and attendance in the house. Ex Rights to deny against summoners 5) [Speaker] independence allows for critical debates in floor of house. However, parliamentary privileges suffer from various challenges to democratic spirit. 1) [Against Constitutionalism] because of high discretion and vested powers. 2) [Conflict of Interest] where house even cannot judge in their own case. 3) [Chilling effect on Media] by inactivity enquire. Ex The Hindu case in Tamil Nadu Assembly. 4) [Checks & Balance] is eroded as the

parliament exercise huge discretion. 5) [Fundamental rights] of others are violated. Ex Karnataka Assembly case against journalists. NCDRC called for codification of privileges. Independent Tribunals need to be constituted for every Acts breach of privilege. [Article 19(2)] need to be amended for live with parliamentary privileges. Hence, parliamentary privileges should be guided by [Spirit of Democracy] and [Spirit of Constitutionalism] limited powers to truly embody the [CULTURE OF DEMOCRACY] in India.

243 words1 paragraphs

Conclusion

Hence, parliamentary privileges should be guided by Spirit of Democracy and Spirit of Constitutionalism limited powers to truly embody the CULTURE OF DEMOCRACY in India.

25 words

Diagram

Steps required for codification of privileges - NCRDRC called for codification, Independent Tribunals needed, Article 19(2) amendment required

Topper

WASIM-UR-RAHMAN

AIR 1572025

Subject & Paper

GS2GS2

Topic

Parliament and State Legislatures - Structure, Functioning, Powers & Privileges

Powers and Privileges

Parliamentary Privileges and their Significance

Writing Stats

268

Total words

1

Paragraphs

analytical

Tone