MM

MUTHUARASI MAIR 225· 2025

Question Q.4GS2GS2

Subordination of investigative agencies to the executive is fraught with disastrous consequences. Discuss the statement in light of the evolution of the Central Bureau of Investigation and its 'caged parrot'.

Open scan (p.4)

Introduction

Supreme court observed that selective use of Central Bureau of Investigation by executive at caged parrot.

16 words

Main Body

Subordination of Investigation agencies - By executive as its consequence Privatization of Investigation agencies: (1) In Appointments i placing/Appointing persons with Vested interest ii prospective of post retirement employ must for office holder deducting their Independence (2) To Privatigete politically motivated charge: ii Using enforcement directorate against opposition leaders and political members belonging to regional parties a CBI and ED raids in members of opposition Consequences: (1) promoting Vested interest and Sovereignty Independence at investigative agencies a Elongation of tenure of CBI director (2) Undermines Federal principles as true agencies were used against State political body members b It determines federal principles (3) promote Rule of men >Rule of law Agency. (4) affects Individual Liberty and Freedom - as concentrated in of Vested prejudized details investigation at other criminal delayed justice (5) district centre-state relation: - Around state has already Kilkitrawnn General consent given to CBI which In turn due auditor future Investigation in particular state b it requires case by case approval Recently Tamilnadu Withdrawal (6) loss of Credibility and public trust on Investigation agencies on long run. Vibrancy of Investigative agencies should be maintained For effective access to Justice Under Suspwell Tripathi case Supreme Court observed . Their subordination of executive should be done away to ensure Independence

210 words1 paragraphs

Conclusion

Their subordination of executive should be done away to ensure Independence

11 words

Topper

MUTHUARASI M

AIR 2252025

Subject & Paper

GS2GS2

Topic

Executive, Judiciary, Ministries and Pressure Groups

Executive

Independence of Investigative Agencies and Separation of Powers

Writing Stats

237

Total words

1

Paragraphs

academic

Tone