ZA

Zinnia AuroraAIR 6· 2025

Question 2GS2GS2

The Supreme Court, in recent verdict, prescribed a time period for the Governor's assent to state legislative bills. What are the implications of this judgement for cooperative federalism and legislative accountability in India? (Answer in 150 words)

Open scan (p.7)

Main Body

Article 200 and 2041 lay down provisions and powers of Governors with regards to legislative assent power, wherein the secret judgement was awarded.

Judgement:

Tamil Nadu Governor vs Govt of Tamil Nadu - Madlock resolution via prescription of 60 days time.

Implications of judgement:

Cooperative federalism:

1Friction between two tiers of government.

e) Governor labelled as 'centre's agent'

2Subordination of gubernatorial powers under state legislature.

e) state can now hold governor mandatory pass bills/reject

3More space for 'reasoned stalemate' by Governor hereafter.
4Time-based exercise of legislative competence by state.

e) Bills on NEET, etc passed by SC in often case.

5Widening power tussle between Union and state - no mechanism of dialogue laid.

Legislative Accountability:

5Constitutional scheme based working with enhanced legislative might.

e) Article 200 tested now.

6Governor accountable to state legislature, not union.

Is viable linkage.

However, Questions remain

5President's power of assent.

e) Advisory sought by President Union Minister under Article 143.

6Discretionary power borrowed - constitutional puffery of state by Governor with emphasis on ARC-1 recommendation on consensus - based Gubernatorial office, reformed union relations called.
189 words5 paragraphs
Examiner score
0.9/10

Open original scan

Page 7

Topper

Zinnia Aurora

AIR 62025

Subject & Paper

GS2GS2

Topic

Federal Structure - Functions, Responsibilities, Devolution of Powers and Finances

Federalism

Governor's Powers and Federal Relations

Writing Stats

189

Total words

5

Paragraphs

analytical

Tone