Question 16GS2GS2

There is a need to ensure better ethical standards, accountability and management of temples in India. Discuss in the context of issues associated with state intervention in management of temples.

Open scan (p.38)

Answer

Introduction

Indian model of secularism allows state intervention in secular matters of religion (Article 25(2))

14 words

Main Body

Indian model of secularism allows state intervention in secular matters of religion (Article 25(2)).

Issues with state intervention in temple management:

1Reduced autonomy of religious institutions under Article 26.

2May violate essential religious practices, integral to religion.

3Ineffective management can create legal voids (eg recent Vaishno Devi stamp).

4Induction of bureaucracy can hurt religious sentiment due to lack of knowledge.

However, there is need for regulation:

5Possibility of corruption, mismanagement due to huge amount of funds involved.

6May carry violations fundamental rights in the name of religion (eg: Sabarimala).

3Handling of secular activities related to accommodation, queues management of crowds (eg: high crowd in Tirupati).

4Preparation of crisis structures for pilgrimages located in seismic zones (eg: Amarnath).

(contdupstay in Uttarkhand on proposed state regulation)

However, there is need for regulator:

1Possibility of corruption, mismanagement due to huge amount of funds involved.

2May carry violations fundamental rights in the name of religion (eg: Sabarimala).

3Handling of secular activities related to accommodation, queues management of crowds (eg: high crowd in Tirupati).

4Preparation of crisis structures for pilgrimages located in seismic zones (eg: Amarnath).

Way forward:

1Engaging community & religious leaders also for self regulation.

2Encouraging practice disclosure of funds & usage.

3Supporting management of lord pilgrims, accommodations.

4Upholding Constitutional morality to ensure equal rights to all irrespective of caste & worship.

5Balancing Article 26 with Article 25(2).

Indian temples are both sources of heritage and uphold idea of secularism.

256 words5 paragraphs

Conclusion

Indian temples are both sources of heritage and uphold idea of secularism.

12 words

Examiner score

1.6/10

Open original scan

Page 38

Topper

Aayushi Bansal

AIR 72022

Subject & Paper

GS2GS2

Topic

Indian Constitution - Historical Underpinnings, Evolution, Features, Amendments, Significant Provisions and Basic Structure

Significant Provisions

Secularism and Article 25(2)

Writing Stats

282

Total words

Paragraphs

analytical

Tone