AM

Aditya MathurAIR 98· 2929

Question 3Discuss with the help of relevant case lawsGS2GS2

भारत के सुप्रीम न्यायालय ने केंद्रीकृत सत्ता एवं क्षेत्रीय स्वायत्तता को संतुलित रूप से तत्पर करते भारत के संघवाद में अनूठी विषमता को बनाए रखा है। न्यायालय द्वारा दिए गए प्रासंगिक पूर्वबर्ती निर्णयों को संदर्भित रूप से तत्पर करते भारत के संघवाद में अनूठी विषमता को बनाए रखा है। न्यायालय द्वारा दिए गए प्रासंगिक पूर्वबर्ती निर्णयों की सहायता से व्याख्या कीजिए। (उत्तर 150 शब्दों में दीजिए) The Supreme Court of India has upheld unique asymmetry in India's federalism by intricately balancing centralized authority and regional autonomy. Discuss with the help of relevant case laws. (Answer in 150 words)

Open scan (p.10)

Introduction

The Supreme Court has upheld federalism as basic feature of Constitution which is a unique blend of federalism & unitary nature

21 words

Main Body

The Supreme Court has upheld federalism as basic feature of Constitution which is a unique blend of federalism & unitary nature (SR Bommai Case, 1994). Unique AsymmetryCentre has more power not all in any Constitution Entire solely Sovereignty & Judici. Balancing Centralized AuthorityUpheld Emergency Provisions: As constitutional and within legitimate power of Union (Minerva Mills Case).Promoted Union Supremacy: By ensuring higher powers to Centre upheld.

The Supreme Court has upheld federalism as basic feature of Constitution which is a unique blend of federalism & unitary nature (SR Bommai Case, 1994)

Unique AsymmetryCentre has more power
not vested in any constitution
Ensure unity & integrity

Balancing Centralized Authority

Upheld Emergency Provisions: as constitutional and within legitimate power of Union (Minerva Mills Case)
Promoted Union Supremacy: by ensuring higher powers & Centre upheld.

Uphold Regional Autonomy

◎ Upheld State Rights: which are independent & supreme in own sphere (GWV Uisuay)

◎ No Ambiguity Dismissal: of state govt under Art. 356 to ensure no misuse (Rameshwar Prasad case)

◎ Ambiguities in Central Action: liable to be set aside (Rajendra Shah case)

Supreme Court has ensured cooperative federalism in India by balancing rights of Union & Regional States (Prof. Chandra Barkavi Commission)

210 words5 paragraphs2 bullet points

Conclusion

Supreme Court has ensured cooperative federalism in India by balancing rights of Union & Regional States

16 words

Examiner score
1.05/10

Open original scan

Page 10

Topper

Aditya Mathur

AIR 982929

Subject & Paper

GS2GS2

Topic

Federal Structure - Functions, Responsibilities, Devolution of Powers and Finances

Federalism

Supreme Court's role in Indian Federalism

Writing Stats

247

Total words

5

Paragraphs

2

Bullets

formal academic

Tone