HS

HARSHDEEP SAGARAIR 299· 2025

Question 13GS2GS2

[DS] Deputy Speaker acts as the interim speaker when the main speaker is absent. She enjoys all powers of the speaker in that instance.

Open scan (p.33)

Main Body

DS goes beyond ceremonial significance and is indispensable

i) Constitutional provision for Deputy Speaker – instituted in [Art 93] itself.

ii) Not secondary to speaker

Equal powers when acting as speaker
Normal MP otherwise

iii) She can vote in 1st instance if tied.

iv) Gives voice to the opposition

DS from opposition party by convention

v) All power privileges also provided

Regular privileges [Art 105, 1947]
Speakers privilege [Art 93, when acting as speaker]
vi) Becomes voice initiated in a coalition governmentactive role in debate and discussion.

Implication of polarized spaces:

i) It is a sign of ruling party's dominanceDS speaker decides election of DS

ii) It affects the constitutional morality of the parliament.

Prevents critique of the government
iii) Misuse of leader of opposition Act, 197710% rule used to disallow opposition (Inattendance)

and its personnel [Leader of Opposition, Deputy Speaker etc].

iii) Many committees lose one office leader [headed by DS by default].

(b) Parliamentary Standing Committee

Needful Improvements:

i) Recognize opposition despite 10% rule

ii) Set time line for DS election

iii) Ensure hearing dates

iv) Assign set days for DS to head the parliamentary write opposition leading the agenda

Hence, Deputy Speaker must become the 'instrument' of ensuring parliamentary discipline and balance.

217 words22 paragraphs6 bullet points

Conclusion

Hence, Deputy Speaker must become the 'instrument' of ensuring parliamentary discipline and balance.

13 words

Examiner score
1.27/10

Open original scan

Page 33

Topper

HARSHDEEP SAGAR

AIR 2992025

Subject & Paper

GS2GS2

Topic

Parliament and State Legislatures - Structure, Functioning, Powers & Privileges

Structure and Functioning

Deputy Speaker

Writing Stats

230

Total words

22

Paragraphs

6

Bullets