Question Q.12 (continued case analysis)GS4GS2
Ethical issues, options, and course of action for Municipal Commissioner in construction accident case
Main Body
a) Ethical Issues Involved in the Case:
Bribery/Corruption: The personal aide offering a ₹2 crore apartment is a direct bribe.
Coercion and Threat: Threatening to file an SC/ST complaint is unethical intimidation.
Conflict of Interest: Political pressure and personal relationships with powerful minister.
Duty to Public: Deaths of workers demand accountability, not cover-up.
Accountability: Negligence by building inspector and previous commissioner.
Justice for victims: Families of deceased workers deserve compensation.
Institutional integrity: Covering up would erode public confidence in municipal governance.
b) Options Available:
1Accept the bribe and settle – UNETHICAL – Violates duty, encourages further corruption.
2Conduct thorough independent investigation reporting factually without fear.
3Seek guidance from higher authorities (State Commissioner, Chief Secretary).
4Approach anti-corruption agencies (CBI/Vigilance).
5Document all communications including the private meeting and threat.
c) Selected Course of Action – Explain:
I will conduct an impartial, thorough investigation:
Hold the builder and previous commissioner accountable
Recommend prosecution under IPC for criminal negligence
Ensure compensation to victim families
Institute disciplinary action against building inspector
Report honestly despite political pressure
Document the bribery attempt and threat
Approach CBI/Vigilance for independent investigation
Strengthen building code compliance mechanisms
This upholds constitutional oath, rule of law, and public trust
218 words6 paragraphs16 bullet points
Conclusion
By adhering to duty and ethics despite threats, the commissioner fulfills constitutional obligations and maintains institutional integrity, protecting public interest over personal safety.
23 words
Examiner score
1.8/10Open original scan
Page 54
Topper
Gaurav Kumar
AIR 3772025
Subject & Paper
GS4GS2
Topic
Role of Civil Services in a Democracy
Ethical dilemmas in public service and accountability
Corruption, accountability, duty to public, and rule of law
Writing Stats
241
Total words
6
Paragraphs
16
Bullets
formal and analytical
Tone