AS

Ashi Sharma

Question 4GS2GS2

What is the significance of the 'leader of Opposition' in the Indian parliamentary system? How does the role of the opposition contribute to the checks and balances in a democracy?

Open scan (p.11)

Main Body

After remaining vacant, the post of leader of opposition post has been filled in the 18th LS. He is the leader of the single largest opposition party/coalition and enjoys the same status as that of cabinet minister.

Significance of LoOP:

1Leadership: to the opposition group in the house.
2Alternate viewpoints : of opposition on key policies are expressed by him on behalf of the larger group.
3Impartiality: LoOP is part of the high-powered committees responsible for appointment of CEC & ECs, lokpal, CVC, CTC, NHRC etc CBT director etc., his presence colours potential appointments.

Roles of Opposition:

1Accountability: from government by using parliamentary tools like

question hour, zero hour, calling attention motion, censure motion, adjournment motion, no confidence motion et

2Participate in parliamentary committees : like public accounts committees, DRCs, committees on PSU and contribute to policy evaluation and legislative scrutiny.
3Optical general data bill → joint parliament committee
4Raise issues of national concern : like corruption, geopolitical developments (Bangla desh crisis), student drawings in Delhi etc and seek action from government
5Financial Propriety: opposition participates in budget discussions and securing of demand for grants.

To further strengthen opposition practise in the house, India should explore UK practise of shadow cabinet.

The preamble is the moral compass of the constitution encapsulating its core ideals.

Sovereignty: ensures viability to take policy decisions independently without external interference and in national interest.

(A) India has maintained its neutrality in ongoing wars in Russia & Israel in line with strategic autonomy

Secularism: ensures establishment of a welfare state to create a society with social, economical and political justice. [circled notation: "capitalism & socialism"] Constitution enclosing: separates the realms of religion and state, and allows for preservation of minority rights and religious reform.

(B) right to freedom of religion under article 25-28 (Part III)

Democracy: is the rule of peoples sovereignty. Abraham Lincoln defined it as a government of the people, by the people and for the people. Constitutional provisions reflecting democratic others—

(C) universal adult suffrage, right to freedom of expression, rule of law, parliamentary accountability etc.

Therefore preamble's values are the foundation of our polity and should act as the most vital in policy formulation.

As per the recommendations of the dishos committee the GoI passed the 103CA4 to provide 10% reservation to EWS in public employment and educational institution.

Implications

Positive

1ensure economic justice for the EWS.
2per capita income in India is around 2L/annum
2provide opportunity for skilled mobility
3realise value of equality of opportunity in premise
4help decrease income inequality
(A) Top 1% in India10% of wealth.
5help decrease poverty

(C) 16% population per multidimensionally (NITI)

Negative

1erased the 50% limit laid down by SC in Indra Sawhney judgement

(D) priorities equity + equality over limit

(E) ambiguities in identification of beneficiaries

(G) issues of fake certificates

(H) economic class as a criteria for affirmative action is not explicitly mentioned in the constitution

(I) excludes only a few as more than 80% populationEWS

(J) decrease pool of seats for SC/ST/OLCs.

The equity of any policy lies in its implementation. The SC had upheld the validity of 103 CA4 now the 60:1 must ensure its benefit reach intended beneficiaries.

547 words10 paragraphs

Conclusion

Therefore preamble's values are the foundation of our polity and should act as the most vital in policy formulation. The equity of any policy lies in its implementation. The SC had upheld the validity of 103 CA4 now the 60:1 must ensure its benefit reach intended beneficiaries.

47 words

  • ensures economic justice
  • provides opportunity for skilled mobility
  • realises equality of opportunity
  • helps decrease income inequality and poverty

Topper

Ashi Sharma

Subject & Paper

GS2GS2

Topic

Parliament and State Legislatures - Structure, Functioning, Powers & Privileges

Structure and Functioning

Leader of Opposition

Writing Stats

594

Total words

10

Paragraphs

analytical

Tone