AA

ASAD AQEELAIR 321· 2025

Question Q15GS2GS2

In a democratic society, individual rights and freedoms are always balanced against the larger interests of society and the state. To what extent do the constitutional restrictions on fundamental rights strike a balance between individual liberty and societal interests? What factors are considered in evaluating the reasonableness of such restrictions?

Open scan (p.33)

Introduction

Democratic rights enshrined under Article 19 envisage individual liberty, to exert any individual reaches its true potential and participate in the democratic process.

23 words

Main Body

Democratic rights enshrined under Article 19 envisage individual liberty, to exert any individual reaches its true potential and participate in the democratic process.

Article 19(2) provides for 'Reasonable Restrictions for such freedom so as to maintain social interest.

Restrictions: Balance(freedom & social interest)

1Right to freedom of speech & expression Art19(1)(a)

➜ restricted via defamation, contempt of court, incitement to offence, material security etc

Curbs to managing fueling divided instances in society

2Right to assemble peacefully & without arms

➜ but subject to maintenance of public movement and decining breach' an illegale due element of coercion in it.

3Right to form association, union, cooperatives

➜ such associations subject to public order and morality

eg: Existing sensuion-groups via UAPA 1967

4Right to move freely throughout avran

➜ but ensuring intestkness of tribal security and cultural via

foreigners order for HP, AAI;
Inner light permit Require - Neutral Nagaland, Mizoram).
5Rights to profession, travel etc
➜ subject to public interests and moralityregulations on profession.

strict prohibition & elimination of human trafficking etc.

Factors for evaluating 'reasonableness':

1Test of proportionality

➜ restriction proportionate to the ends.

eg: Going for granular regulations even without ban

2Ensuring enactness of secular exalts of sindia

eg: Prohibition on forceful conversion to Q religion.

3Balancing 'competing rights'

eg: Right to protest vs Right to Movement.

➜ Balancing freedom and social interest are ensured in consonance mile Large natural growth.

243 words12 paragraphs2 bullet points

Conclusion

Balancing freedom and social interest are ensured in consonance mile Large natural growth.

13 words

  • Uses constitutional provisions
  • Identifies key restrictions
  • Structured approach
  • Covers multiple fundamental rights
  • Provides specific examples
  • Links to constitutional articles
  • Identifies key tests of reasonableness
  • Provides concrete examples
  • Concludes with balanced approach

Topper

ASAD AQEEL

AIR 3212025

Subject & Paper

GS2GS2

Topic

Indian Constitution - Historical Underpinnings, Evolution, Features, Amendments, Significant Provisions and Basic Structure

Fundamental Rights

Reasonable restrictions on rights and balance with social interests

Writing Stats

279

Total words

12

Paragraphs

2

Bullets

analytical

Tone