Question 18GS2GS2
The recent allegations of malpractices in voter rolls updation just before the polls in Maharashtra have started a debate.
Main Body
It's Should Adhar be Mandatorily Linked.
1The Adhar should not be mandated as it is a document of presidency not citizenship - (Amit Shah)
2Large scale errors of omission could occur by MGNREGA Adhar linkage led to omission in beneficiaries
3Lack of documents with a large section of the population.
4Make the roll updation process complicated.
ECT has not talked about the Adhar mandate.
Arguments for linkage
1Possibility of increased inclusion in the process and include vulnerable sections by Stronger give vote in 2021
2Better document linkage for records uniformity
3Online portal could easily be created for grievances
4Opposition demands will be fulfilled.
Way Forward
1Application can be made for Voter ID and Adhar for new voters simultaneously.
2Social impact assessment could be
done.
3Clarity on utility of Adhar should be revisited by the government.
4Online governance through eCI IDs on Vigilodher
The correct SIR revision in Bihar is a testament to the need for reforms in Voter ID creation. The linkage could prove to be a useful tool with the
183 words16 paragraphs
Conclusion
The correct SIR revision in Bihar is a testament to the need for reforms in Voter ID creation. The linkage could prove to be a useful tool with the
29 words
- Identifies document-citizenship distinction
- Provides concrete example of MGNREGA errors
- Acknowledges documentation gaps in population
- Notes procedural complexity
- Provides arguments in support of Aadhar linkage
- Suggests parallel application process
- Mentions social impact assessment
- Addresses vulnerable sections
- Provides specific case study from Bihar
- Suggests online governance mechanisms
- Addresses clarity issues
- Concludes with practical utility
Topper
Aditya Talwar
AIR 2702025
Subject & Paper
GS2GS2
Topic
Electoral Reforms
Voter Registration and Electoral Integrity
Malpractices in Voter Rolls Updation
Writing Stats
212
Total words
16
Paragraphs
Balanced and reform-oriented
Tone