AS

Annapurna Singh· 2023

Question Q.4GS2GS2

सूचना का अधिकार अधिनियम 2005 की सफलताओं और सीमाओं का विश्लेषण कीजिए। (Answer in 250 words) 15 marks.

Open scan (p.4)

Main Body

Right to Information Act - 2005

Right to Information is a democratic tool for citizens to know about government functioning. Given rise to:

1. Transparency & accountability at all govt levels

2. Public participation & strengthening democracy

3. Reduction in corruption & abuse of power

4. Strengthen civil society watch dog functions

5. Judicial intervention in RTI issues

However, RTI also has faced several limitations/challenges:

1. Delayed responses - officers often provide delayed responses or file extension

2. Incomplete disclosure - information provided is incomplete/censored

3. Harassment of RTI activists - vigilance/suppression of information seekers

4. Inadequate resources - lack of proper documentation & digitalization in govt departments

5. Abuse of exemptions - Excessive use of exemptions under Section 8 & 9 of RTI act

6. Inadequate training - of officers to handle RTI requests

7. Culture of secrecy still prevails in bureaucracy

8. Pendency in cases - large number of appeals at CIC

To improve RTI:

1. Proactive disclosure - making information public before being asked

2. Capacity building - training of govt officials

3. Digitalization - of all govt records & documents

4. Strict timeline - for disposal of RTI requests

5. Penalties - for deliberate delay/suppression of information

6. Independence to CIC - to function free from pressure

7. Media education - to create RTI awareness among masses

8. RTI index - of various departments for transparency

Thus, RTI act is indeed a democratic tool but needs strengthening through proper implementation, resources allocation & cultural shift from secrecy to transparency.

253 words26 paragraphs

Conclusion

Thus, RTI act is indeed a democratic tool but needs strengthening through proper implementation, resources allocation & cultural shift from secrecy to transparency.

23 words

Answer continues on next page
  • Comprehensive listing of successes and limitations
  • Provides specific solutions to address identified challenges
  • References key sections of the RTI Act
  • Discusses both top-down (implementation) and bottom-up (awareness) measures
  • Balanced analysis acknowledging RTI as a democratic tool while highlighting improvements needed

Topper

Annapurna Singh

2023

Subject & Paper

GS2GS2

Topic

Governance, Transparency, Accountability and E-governance

Transparency and Accountability

Right to Information Act 2005

Writing Stats

276

Total words

26

Paragraphs

Analytical and constructive

Tone