AR

Aniket RanjanAIR 48· 2025

Question Q.13GS2GS2

The cooperative nature of Indian federalism is being increasingly challenged by emerging differences in Centre-State relations. Discuss. What steps can be taken to strengthen the cooperative spirit of Indian federalism?

Open scan (p.29)

Main Body

Cooperative federalism is the essential feature of our Democracy wherein the different states along with centre come together and work for balanced and proper growth.

Challenges faced by Centre-State Relations:

# Division of states between Centre and states are disproportionate.

Union list has more subjects than State list.
Also, Parliamentary law prevail over state law.

# All India Services are allocated by centre (DoPT) and the states do not have much autonomy in it.

# States depend upon the centre devolution of funds like GST Compensation, Finance Commission devolution.

Asymmetry in devolution. (44%)states

# States do not have much autonomy in bills passage as Governor is in the centre appointee. (Ref) Recent instances of Tamil Nadu, Punjab Government clashing that governor withholds the bills.

Steps taken to strengthen the Cooperative federalism:

1Augment the State functions and functioneries → by given more subjects in hand.
2Implement the recommendation of Sarkaria and Punchhi Commission
Governors form out of state.
CM should be consulted.
3Need to provide more funds and balanced approach in tax devolution.

Parliamentary privileges are provided to the MPs by the Constitution as per the mandate of Article 105 of the Constitution.

No Scrutiny against the MP, for anything said in house in court.

PrivilegesMPs are free from civil cases, discuss matters about 40 days before and after the session.

Permission of chair is needed on arrest.

These privileges are given to MPs to discharge their duty in more efficient and transparent manner.

However, the problems with the privileges are:

1They are often misused for personal gain. (Eg) politicization of caste.
2Hate speech and hatred against other religion or community.
3The powers of MPs are misused in many criminal and electoral cases.

Need for Responsible exercise of these privileges:

1It is required as the public servants are the people's representative and they need to be responsible in their actions.
2They are the aspirational of the public, who will work for their upliftment.
3They are the one who has the public funds → as the trustee of the public.
4They are the role model and public official, image of democratic India.

Way forward:

# Introduce the training session for MPs and MLAs

# Stringent law for misuse of privilege & powers.

Hence these privileges are to be used in the best and effective manner.

Fundamental Rights (Part III) are the essential feature of our Constitution. It has several rights which empowers the citizen to live a life with basic human needs. However, there are certain restrictions on it:

1Right to Equality (Article 14-18)
Equality before lawRule of law.
RestrictionAffirmative Actions for women, children, SC & ST.
2Right to freedom (Article 19)
Freedom of speech & expression.
Freedom of thought, faith
Freedom of movement inside the country.
RestrictionPublic order, Morality, Defamation, security, court order, etc.
3Right to life and personal liberty (Article 21)
Restrictionin pervise euthanasia
Done any heinous crime like rape, murder, etc.
4It has several other restriction like → emergency provisions (Article 358) and martial law.

Here the ordinary rights do not

junction.

5In the case of COVID-19 lockdown, the movement rights were sticted.
6In the purview of HIV infected an invisible prostitute, their movement right are resticted.
7State rights are resticted during President rule.

However there are fine balance between the individual instects and societal interests as:

1Ends are greater than means → providing good for maximum number of people.
2Distributive Justice → several environmental laws are on this.

Hence, these rights are used only to an extent it provided the balance with the societal needs & norms.

631 words28 paragraphs

Conclusion

Therefore, the new India @ 2047 need the effort of state & centre to collaborate and cooperate.

17 words

  • Provides clear definition of cooperative federalism
  • Identifies specific structural issues in centre-state relations
  • Uses recent examples (Tamil Nadu, Punjab)
  • Quantifies asymmetry with specific percentages
  • References important commissions (Sarkaria and Punchhi)
  • Provides specific recommendations
  • Connects to India 2047 vision
  • Clearly identifies the constitutional basis
  • Lists specific privileges granted to MPs
  • Emphasizes the purpose of privileges
  • Identifies concrete problems with misuse of privileges
  • Provides clear rationale for accountability
  • Offers practical solutions (training, stringent laws)
  • Connects privileges to democratic values
  • Clearly identifies constitutional foundation
  • Starts with specific article references
  • Mentions affirmative action as example of restriction
  • Covers multiple fundamental rights
  • Provides specific restrictions for each right
  • References emergency provisions and martial law
  • Provides concrete contemporary examples
  • Clearly articulates the balance principle
  • References distributive justice concept

Topper

Aniket Ranjan

AIR 482025

Subject & Paper

GS2GS2

Topic

Federal Structure - Functions, Responsibilities, Devolution of Powers and Finances

Federalism

Centre-State relations and cooperative federalism

Writing Stats

648

Total words

28

Paragraphs

analytical

Tone