Question Q.3GS2GS2
The Speaker's inclination to cater to party loyalties often undermines the dignity and impartiality of the office, eroding public trust in the legislative process. Analyse with the help of recent examples.
Main Body
In the 18th Lok Sabha, due to strong opposition, the election of Lok Sabha Speaker held in the history with only 3 instances.
Speaker is the presiding officer of the Lok Sabha, on whose behalf the Lok Sabha functions properly.
Therefore, the need of impartial speakers is needed.
Instances of party loyalties
1Speaker often given more time to party leader of his party. Less time for opposition.
2Speaker, does the voice vote in many cases.
3The issue of Manipuri and NEET leakage were not discussed properly.
4Suspension as expunge of words spoken by opposition.
5Less number of private bills got passed.
Solutions to be done
1As per Anti-defection law, speaker law singer from the party → to maintain transparency.
2Allow the opposition to put forward their issues.
The temple of democracy will work only when, the speaker is fair and impartial.
148 words13 paragraphs
- Relevant and recent examples from 18th Lok Sabha
- Structured presentation with instances and solutions
- Identifies specific problems with current practice
- Proposes concrete solutions
- Concluding statement on importance of fair speaker
- Provides concrete examples of Speaker's partisan conduct
- Lists multiple instances showing pattern of behavior
- Proposes solutions with legal framework (Anti-defection law)
- Concluding statement emphasizes importance of impartiality
Topper
Aniket Ranjan
AIR 482025
Subject & Paper
GS2GS2
Topic
Parliament and State Legislatures - Structure, Functioning, Powers & Privileges
Structure and Functioning
Role and responsibilities of Speaker, party loyalties in parliamentary functioning
Writing Stats
148
Total words
13
Paragraphs
formal and analytical with contemporary references
Tone