AP

ADITYA PATHAKAIR 189· 2025

Question 3GS2GS2

Examine the electoral reforms suggested by various commissions. What are the major challenges in implementing these reforms?

Open scan (p.3)

Introduction

Electoral reforms have been advocated by various commissions to strengthen democratic institutions:

12 words

Main Body

Electoral reforms have been advocated by various commissions to strengthen democratic institutions:

Key Electoral Reforms Recommended:

1. Kosan Committee (1975) - Recommended:

Limitation of campaign expenditure
Curbing of electoral expenses
Stricter enforcement of electoral laws

2. Goswami Committee (1979) - Focused on:

Organization of elections
Reduction of expenditure
Election Commission autonomy

3. Dinesh Goswami Committee (1990) - Suggested:

Disclosure of candidates' antecedents
Prohibition of party-hopping
Stricter election expense rules
Public funding of elections

4. Inderjit Gupta Committee (2000) - Recommended:

Strengthening of party finance regulations
Transparency in campaign funding
Stricter penalties for violations

5. Law Commission reports - Advocated:

Electoral bonds (later implemented)
Proportional representation
Simultaneous elections

Major Implementation Challenges:

1. Political Consensus - Parties having different interests; lack of consensus on sensitive reforms

2. Constitutional Amendments - Many reforms require constitutional changes

3. Financial Implications - Public funding would require substantial budget allocation

4. Enforcement Issues - Monitoring of campaign spending is difficult

5. Party Funding Opacity - Illegal funding sources hard to trace

6. Role of Money Power - Influences candidate selection and elections

7. Communal and Regional Pressures - Local politics override national norms

8. Administrative Capacity - Election Commission's limited resources for monitoring

9. Resistance from Established Parties - Those with resources resist transparency

224 words9 paragraphs16 bullet points

Conclusion

While electoral reforms are essential for strengthening democracy and reducing corruption, implementation faces political, constitutional, and administrative hurdles. A consensus-building approach and willingness from major political parties are essential for meaningful reform.

32 words

  • Detailed reference to specific committees and their recommendations
  • Clear categorization of reforms by different commissions
  • Balanced discussion of implementation challenges
  • Recognition of political consensus as a key barrier
  • Discussion of practical enforcement issues

Topper

ADITYA PATHAK

AIR 1892025

Subject & Paper

GS2GS2

Topic

Electoral Reforms

Reform Commissions and Recommendations

Implementation Challenges

Writing Stats

268

Total words

9

Paragraphs

16

Bullets

Formal and analytical

Tone