AA

Aditya Agarwal· 2024

Question Q11GS2GS2

16वें वित्त आयोग की शर्तें पिछले वित्त आयोगों से कैसे अलग हैं? हाल के वर्षों में विभिन्न राज्यों में आर्थिक असमानताओं को कम करने वाले कारकों की जांच करते हुए, क्रमिक वित्त आयोग अनुपातहीन असमानताओं को कम करने में सहायक रहे हैं? In what ways are the terms of reference of the 16th Finance Commission different from that of the previous Finance Commissions? Despite increasingly progressive devolution by subsequent Finance Commissions, examine the factors that propel economic disparities across various States.

Open scan (p.24)

Introduction

16th Finance Commission has been set up by the President under Article 280 of the Indian constitution.

17 words

Main Body

Arvind Panagariya as its chairman have to provide the formula for distribution of taxes for the period 2026-2031.

Terms of Reference of 16th Finance Commission

To devise the formula for :-
vertical devolution of taxes between central and state.
horizontal distri button of taxes between the states
To provide the suggestion on ways to augment the consolidated fund of state
Grants-in-aids to certain states.
Funds to the Disaster Management Fund.

These items are different from Previous Finance Commissions :-

Do not specifically mention for providing funds for healthcare and education
funds are not tied to any reforms by the state.
funds to local government not mentioned

previous finance Commissions:

5th Finance Commission: Allotment of funds to some states Categorised as special category states

14th Finance Commission: Increased vertical devolution from ~32% to 42%. and 3CS under status was no longer used.

used the 1971 population as criteria

15th Finance Commission:

41/ vertical devolution and 17. to newly created UT of Jammu and Kashmir

— Used 2011 population census. Also population measures and tax efforts considered in criteria.

However, some factors has led to economic disparities among states :

i) Increasing cess and surcharge reducing the divisible pool of taxes

ii) Income distance given high weightage

(iii) State contributing more such as Tamil Nadu, Maharashtra, Karnataka getting lessand Bihar, UPmajor receiver.

iii) Dependence on the aid — aid curse — despite receiving funds, no effort to maintain fiscal consolidation and growth.

iv) High revenue expenditure leading to fiscal deficit of states. (⊕) OPS announced in some states .

16 Finance commission forms important part of fiscal federalism of the country. States must manage their finances to reduce disparities

291 words19 paragraphs
  • Identifies Article 280 as constitutional basis
  • Lists key terms of reference clearly
  • Names chairman and period of reference
  • Covers both vertical and horizontal devolution
  • Compares multiple Finance Commissions
  • Quantifies devolution percentages
  • Discusses special category states
  • References 1971 census criteria
  • Identifies specific factors causing disparities
  • Provides state examples (Tamil Nadu, Maharashtra vs Bihar, UP)
  • Discusses structural issues (cess, surcharge)
  • Mentions contemporary schemes (OPS)
  • Connects to fiscal federalism

Topper

Aditya Agarwal

2024

Subject & Paper

GS2GS2

Topic

Functions and Responsibilities of the Union and the States

Devolution of Powers and Finances up to Local Levels

Finance Commission - Terms of Reference and devolution mechanisms

Writing Stats

308

Total words

19

Paragraphs