S

Sachin

Question 5(b)GS4GS1

Distinguish between administrative, legal and professional accountability. Despite multiple institutional accountability mechanisms, the government has failed to make a dent in systematic corruption. What do you think are the reasons for the poor performance of accountability mechanisms?

Open scan (p.26)

Introduction

Accountability uses to institutionalized mechanism that ensures:

7 words

Main Body

i) Accountability - justification for an action taken

ii) Enforcement - sanctions & penalties for unjustified action

iii) Responsiveness - internal sense of responsibility

Accountability

Administrative | Legal | Professional

accountability with input to administrative hierarchy or code conduct | - writ legislation laws, rule, regulation or constitution | - writ accountability value or deols proposed Standards

(Ex) Civil service conduct rule | (Ex) Whistleblower act | (Ex) NMC Proposed Standards of Doctors

Reason for poor performance of accountability mechanisms:

1Institutional issue spilt to each institution - law of corporate - law of property - lack of time
2Accountability considers qualitative aspect of an action & not its qualitative outcome

(Ex) Moral minimalism taken by official

3Risk of collision: the nexus formation between justice provider and those who monitor their performance

(Ex) [illegible] Judicial/Physical interaction monitoring their action

4Political interference - Political leader being the head of parliament requires an act in big or prejudicial manner

(Ex) Favour while monitoring their action

5Poor grievance redressal mechanisms - either absent or not functioning in true spirit
6Poor participation & less awareness of citizenry, civil society regulations & media (Ex) people unaware of whistleblower - what's it of Whistleblower

Therefore, without accountability, administration woebegone is Frankenstein monster which eats its own master.

217 words10 paragraphs1 bullet points

Diagram

Three-column table showing Administrative, Legal, and Professional accountability with examples

  • Clear classification structure
  • Use of diagram
  • Specific examples provided

Topper

Sachin

Subject & Paper

GS4GS1

Topic

Accountability

Types of accountability

Administrative, legal, and professional accountability

Writing Stats

224

Total words

10

Paragraphs

1

Bullets

structured

Tone