Question 12Compare and contrastGS2GS1
'आचरिका' आचार और विशेषाधिकारों के उल्लंघन की गई काम को संभोधने में आचार समिति और विशेषाधिकार समिति की शक्तियों और कार्यकरण को तुलना करें। क्या ये समितियां एक-दूसरे में संसदीय अनुशासन बनाए रखने में परिपूर्ण हैं? (250 शब्द, 15 अंक) Compare and contrast the powers and working of the Ethics Committee and the Privileges Committee in addressing cases of 'unethical' conduct and breach of privileges. How do these Committees complement each other in maintaining parliamentary discipline?
Introduction
Article 105 provides for the privileges and immunities of parliamentarians, but the Ethics and Privileges committee secures the 'ethical' functioning of these privileges.
23 words
Main Body
Ethics Committee vs Privileges Committee comparison table:
Ethics Committee | Privileges Committee
1Deals with unethical conduct of Lok sabha and Rajya sabha. | 1) Deals with specific breaches of privileges, which may lead to unethical conduct.
2Ethics committee deals only with complains of MPs's conduct. eg: sharing of parliament's login details with non-MPs. | 2) Deal with complaints of breaches, within and outside parliament. eg: Publication of proceedings of special section by media house
5mainly has power of investigation, and submits reports to Speaker. | 5) Has the powers to provide penal and judicial punishment by itself.
3While privilege committee deals with misdemeanor outside the parliament, Ethics committee addresses the unethical behaviour within parliament.
118 words2 paragraphs
Diagram
Comparison table of Ethics Committee vs Privileges Committee with their functions and powers
- Clear tabular comparison
- Specific examples provided
- Good use of illustrative cases
Topper
Ritika Chitlangia
Subject & Paper
GS2GS1
Topic
Modern Indian History
Post-independence Consolidation
Writing Stats
141
Total words
2
Paragraphs
formal academic
Tone