AT

Anjali ThakurAIR 43· 2023

Question 20EvaluateGS1GS1

In the context of states in India evaluate the relationship between regional disparity and sentiments of regionalism. Is regionalism antagonistic to the idea of nationalism? (Answer in 150 words) 15 marks.

Open scan (p.53)

Introduction

Regionalism means attaching more affection to the region and wanting or favouring its interest even at the cost of other region.

21 words

Main Body

Relationship between Regional Disparity & Regionalism:

1. less development fuels regionalism eg> Jharkhand separated (2000)

2. Neglect from Administration compared to other region eg> Northeastern Demands -> Greater Nagalim for naga people.

3. Regional Disparity based on distinct identity

3.1 Language -> Bodoland demand

3.2 Ethnicity -> Kuki v/s Meiti (Manipur)

3.3 Religion -> Khalistan movement.

4. Regional disparity based on resource allocation fuels Regionalism eg> Chhattisgarh separation from M.P & now performing well

5. Regional disparity in terms of Administrative development causes dissent eg> Telangana separation (2014) -> due to less developmental efforts and all administrative efforts towards Eastern Andhra pradesh.

Regionalism antagonistic to nationalism:

1. Only focus on regional development rather than nation as a whole

2. Fuels Regional aspirations and causes tensions -> hinders national growth.

3. Regionalism causes separation of people based on different identities eg> In one state like manipur different identities - Naga, Kuki, Meity - they clashes

4. many violent feulled by regionalism eg> In Mumbai and Gujarat -> Attack on migrants of UP-Bihar.

5. fuels son of soil sentiments eg> Haryana giving 75% reservation to local people.

However Both are not antagonistic:

1. regionalism caters to the demands of local people -> enhanced democratic participation

2. Attracts the political attention and thus serves to the cause of people.

3. Serves to the development of Region. eg> Telangana after separation is growing more.

230 words3 paragraphs

Conclusion

Regionalism in itself is not bad but when it takes extreme forms it harms the Indian ethos and nationality. "We are Indians firstly and lastly" - B.R. Ambedkar.

28 words

  • Good use of current affairs (Manipur conflict)
  • Clear categorization of disparity types
  • Relevant historical examples

Topper

Anjali Thakur

AIR 432023

Subject & Paper

GS1GS1

Topic

Effects of Globalization on Indian society

Regionalism

Regionalism

Writing Stats

279

Total words

3

Paragraphs

structured, analytical

Tone