AD

Akansh DhullAIR 3

Question 16Discuss the advantages and challengesGS3GS1

Why is there a shift of labour-intensive industries from China to South and Southeast Asia? Discuss the advantages and challenges for India in this context. (Answer in 250 words)

Open scan (p.41)

Introduction

As China weaponizes its supply chain (tactic of hybrid war), the world is moving towards reshoring based on idea of techna+1. Shift of labour intensive industry:

26 words

Main Body

① Chinanew high middle income country. It has wage premium +80% India, -50% Vietnam, -30% Thailand

② Ageing population in China's 1 child policy, older demographic dividend is over

③ Favourable government policies (eg Vietnamplug and play model relaxed labour laws)

④ Strategic reasons (eg geopolitical)

⑤ Force trade agreements, low income countryD rated exports (eg Bangladeshnew textile hub)
⑥ Rise of skilled workforce + demographic dividend65% of India's populationworking age)

⑦ Advancement in modern skills in South Asia as China moves to capital industry [Flying geese model]

Advantages for India:

① Boost to manufacturing sectorMake In India, PLI scheme
② Create Jobs in Indiatransitionsolve for jobless growth
③ Job led growthmultiplier effect create [rural demandvalues for [inclusive growth] [SDG]
④ Credibility[Stateable supply] chain partner
⑤ Demographic Dividendavoid 90 crore strong workforce
⑥ Create [export] led growthgoods based [Foreign Trade Policy]

⑦ Cheaper labour in India

⑧ Better infrastructure than South East Asian countries [BODB growth

demographic dividend] (eg 65% of India's populationWorking age)
9Advancement in modern skills in South Asia as China moves to capital industry [Flying goose model]

Advantages for India:

① Boost to manufacturing sectorMake In India, PLI scheme
② Create Jobs in Indiatransitionsolve for jobless growth
③ Job led growthmultiplier effect create [rural demandvalues for [inclusive growth] [SDG]
④ Credibility[Stateable supply] chain partner
⑤ Demographic Dividendavoid 90 crore strong workforce
⑥ Create [export] led growthgoods based [Foreign Trade Policy]

⑦ Cheaper labour in India

⑧ Better infrastructure than South East Asian countries [BODB growth

Challenges/Disadvantages for India:

① Employability is an issueonly 51% generally skilled60% in Vietnam. Stringent labour laws vs counterparts

② Stringent labour laws vs counterparts

③ Productivity adjusted wage rate is lower than Cambodia, Thailand for India [East Asian Tigers] part of RCEP, more part of global supply chain

④ High logistics cost [12-13%] LLEADS India

⑤ Democracy led challenge in India vs dictatorship (no dissent)

Way Forward:

① Upskill skilled modern workforce

② Invest summit (eg Maruti in Mayoral) Plug and play infra, industrial corridor

③ Plug and play infra, industrial corridor

④ Balance labour lawsimplement [open code 2019]
391 words5 paragraphs

Conclusion

India should seize this moment to be a preferred alternative. Provide all the necessary support for mfg excellence

18 words

Diagram

Fig 1. shows wage differential between China, India, Vietnam, and Thailand

  • Comprehensive coverage of reasons for shift
  • Multiple factors identified (economic, demographic, geopolitical)
  • Clear comparison of wage differentials
  • Strong linkage to India's advantages
  • Connection to SDG and inclusive growth
  • References relevant government schemes

Topper

Akansh Dhull

AIR 3

Subject & Paper

GS3GS1

Topic

Resource Distribution & Industries

Generic Resource based

Labour-intensive industries shift from China

Writing Stats

435

Total words

5

Paragraphs

analytical and structured

Tone